On a brilliant October afternoon, College senior Caroline Hosey soaked in the sights around her at the Echo Project Music Festival in Fairburn, Ga.: the sun’s brilliant rays, the bands playing for 10,000 fans — and then a man in a frog suit eagerly approaching her. He handed her a pamphlet about cleaning up the Chattahoochee River and provided some tips for saving energy.
Although a music festival veteran, this was Hosey’s first run-in with an environmental message she felt she could put to good use.
“It was just such a friendly vibe, so you want to know what they’re all about,” Hosey said. “Just like any other person wants to talk about music, they just want to talk about the environment. They weren’t making me feel like I was a bad person or preaching at me. They made me feel like I could be a part of something bigger.”
With her sun-kissed hair and tanned skin serving as testaments to her outdoorsy lifestyle, Hosey basked in this new information. Music festivals quench her bottomless voracity for good music, sunshine and — increasingly — sound environmental practices.
“Just to see people that wanted to clean up the environment and be a part of something bigger was the most beautiful experience I’ve ever seen in my life and definitely opened my eyes,” Hosey said.
Across the globe, music festivals are working to balance entertainment and environmentalism. Just as businesses and vendors become keen to this need, green practices have become more common in the festival scene, where an event may now tout its solar-powered stages just as much as its headliners.
Eight of the 10 most popular American outdoor music festivals drawing 20,000 or more people incorporate recycling operations and environmental outreach programs. However, the impact of 20,000 living off a small area of land is hard to offset, as recent audits show.
“It’s an industry that’s difficult to green just because they rely too heavily on people coming — thousands of people coming to one location and all the impacts that are associated with that, with travel,” Jeff Severin, director of Kansas University’s Center for Sustainability, said. He conducted the “sustainability audit” of the festival this year at organizers’ requests.
Recognizing the necessary evil of long-distance travelers — a whopping 95 percent of respondents in the audit traveled in private cars — festival organizers are now advertising their carbon neutrality, meaning they offset the carbon emissions created by the festival by investing in technology that does not release carbon.
Festivals claim their neutrality by estimating their impact — researching where tickets were bought — and then purchasing units of carbon offsets to counteract those journeys.
Essentially, carbon offsets are promises sold by companies to invest in projects that will reduce carbon emissions. However, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has raised many questions about the certifications behind the promises, such as whether the companies selling the offsets are actually following through.
The FTC released a statement in 2007 saying that the carbon offsets festivals often purchase to achieve neutrality can be misleading.
“There’s a heightened potential for deception,” Deborah Platt Majoras, chairwoman of the FTC, said in a January interview with The New York Times.
And after the impact of travel, on-site waste and energy consumption also create an environmental issue, which Severin’s audit of Wakarusa looked into. Auditing the recycling, water and energy usage of a large-scale music festival is unique since most festivals just use rough estimates of waste and energy consumption to make their claims of environmental friendliness.
Part of a team of three Kansas University students, Severin looked into the environmental impact of energy, fuel, transit and waste to assess the sustainability of Wakarusa.
Wakarusa made its most significant strides toward sustainability by significantly reducing fuel consumption, according to the audit. Overall consumption lowered by 15 percent, and all but 31 of the 4,639 gallons of fuel used were biodiesel. Just a year before, the festival used 5,348 gallons of petroleum diesel, meaning Wakarusa reduced petroleum diesel usage by 38 percent in one year.
Like Wakarusa, many festivals show exciting initiatives, only to have those nullified by the remaining unsustainable practices like coal-powered stages and premium campsites.
So while struggling to channel an image of eco-friendliness, festivals haven’t broken the chokehold of cheap, harmful technologies.
While some event organizers scramble to stick an environmental hook onto their event, some use it as the prime selling point. Dave Matthews Band and the Allman Brothers performed for 50,000 spectators at Piedmont Park in September and raised $1.25 million for park conservation and sustainability pursuits.
Besides garnering funds, the concert played a major role in raising awareness about the park’s new initiatives, such as Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED)-certified bathrooms.
Started by Nicolas Bouckaert in 2007, the Echo Project is a three-day music and activism event featuring tents devoted to environmental groups. Other festivals like Bonnaroo have incorporated environmental villages into their event too, but few integrate it so fundamentally into the image of the event.
Echo-veteran Hosey said she was drawn to the inaugural Project because of this tactic. Even if complete neutrality seems out of the question for festivals, by informing and mobilizing young people like Caroline Hosey, festivals may prove their green worth.
“I just want a better world,” Hosey said. “I just want to enjoy good music and spread the love, spread the word about just joining together. That’s what I live for, and I feel like the festival environment provides a really good gate for that.”
Hosey will make her usual festival circuit this summer. But this time, she’ll be there as a volunteer with Clean Vibes, an organization dedicated to recycling, reusing and cleaning up the waste left by festivals. She recognizes not everyone has become as environmentally conscious as she has but says she’s here to clean up until they do.
— Contact Bridget Riley